Note 3: It is interesting that Dreyer, with regard to the view that
cartoons will be a better medium than real films for the retelling of Andersen's
fairy tales, agrees with Danish silent film's pioneer director, Viggo Larsen,
about whom Arnold Hending, among others, writes the following: "[...]
Viggo Larsen's lack of hope for a successful outcome of an adventure film was
that it was his opinion (long before cartoons were created) that only in
cartoons could the right result be achieved. The camera was him, and here he
looked basically right, too realistic! " Quoted from Arnold Hending: The
film and H.C. Andersen. Kandrup & Wunsch. Copenhagen 1955. I have not
been able to determine when Viggo Larsen's statement to Arnold Hending
originated, but on October 22, 1956 he was interviewed on tape about his
pioneering time in Danish film by people from the Danish Film Museum. But there
is a possibility that Viggo Larsen's words about the cartoon as the best medium
for adventure films, especially about H.C. Andersen's adventures, may have been
inspired by e.g. Dreyer's article from January 1939. It does not sound
immediately probable that Viggo Larsen, "long before cartoons were
created", should have thought, "that only in cartoons could the right
result be achieved." In that case, he must have been even very
foresighted, for in 1907 the cartoon medium was largely non-existent, at least
not as a genre yet to be reckoned with.
Nordisk Film's 8 minute long
feature film "Fyrtøjet" can be found in Arnold Hending: Filmen and
H.C.Andersen, page 13ff, and still images from the film can be seen on
pages 11 and 13. In Marguerite Engberg: Danish silent film I-II, the silent
film "Fyrtøjet" " referred to pages 135, 195 and 200.
For the sake of completeness,
it should be mentioned that Nordisk Film's H.C. Andersen adventure film no. 3,
also shot in 1907, was "Ole Lukøje" or "The Night Before
Christians' Birthday". The plot was based on H.C. Andersen's fairy tale
comedy "Ole Lukøje", which had been performed for the first time at
the Casino on March 1, 1850. The film is mentioned in Arnold Hending: The film
and H.C. Andersen, page 14ff. Same place page 15 there is a single still photo
from the film, which strangely enough is not even mentioned by Marguerite
Engberg. But "Ole Lukøje" was Nordisk Film's final farewell to the
production and film adaptation of H.C. Andersen's fairy tales.